1

The Biblical Case for the Location of the Temple: Part 2—The Testimony of Jesus

Anyone who has seen the ancient, massive stone walls of the so-called “temple mount” will at some point think about what Jesus said regarding the destruction of the temple—that no stone would be left upon another as stated by Jesus in Matthew 24:2 and Mark 13:2.  If the walls were part of the temple compound, then why are there still all those stones left?

Did Jesus lie?  Was his statement just a hyperbole (an exaggeration to make a point)?  The excuse is usually given that in Mark 13:2, Jesus was speaking of the temple buildings only, not the outer walls, because Jesus states:  “Seest thou these great buildings?  There shall not be left one stone upon another, that shall not be thrown down.

I would argue that anything that has been built is technically a “building.”  The stone walls consist of four walls.  You could say it is a building without a ceiling.  However, it really doesn’t matter, because in another passage, Jesus states very specifically that “not one stone would be left upon another” of the entire City of Jerusalem in Luke 19:42-44:

And when he was come near, he beheld the CITY [Jerusalem], and wept over it, Saying, If thou hadst known, even thou, at least in this thy day, the things which belong unto thy peace! but now they are hid from thine eyes.  For the days shall come upon thee, that thine enemies shall cast a trench about thee [Jerusalem], and compass thee round, and keep thee in on every side, And shall lay thee even with the ground, and thy children within thee; and they shall not leave in thee [Jerusalem] one stone upon another; because thou knewest not the time of thy visitation.

There is no indication in this passage (or the Matthew and Mark passages) that Jesus was employing hyperbole (exaggerating), so either he was mistaken or lying, (both impossible) OR those stone walls were never a part of Jerusalem nor a part of the temple complex in the first place.  As discussed in Part 1, the Bible makes it clear that the temple was in the City of David, not on the geographical area incorrectly called the temple mount.

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSaveSaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSaveSaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave




The Biblical Case for the Location of the Temple: Part 1

The Bible describes exactly where Solomon’s temple was built in 2 Chronicles 3:1

Then Solomon began to build the house of the LORD at Jerusalem in mount Moriah, where the LORD appeared unto David his father, in the place that David had prepared in the threshingfloor of Ornan the Jebusite.

However, if you don’t know the Old Testament, this won’t mean anything to you. I’m sure you would know where Jerusalem is, but do you know where Mount Moriah is? Do you know the story about David and Ornan the Jebusite? Do you know the relevant history regarding Jebus/Jerusalem from the book of Joshua?

From 2 Chronicles 3:1 we know that Solomon’s Temple was located IN Jerusalem. The book of Ezra also states this plainly in Ezra 1:2,3,5; 2:68; 6:5 among others, and 7:27. Mount Moriah (which is only named in 2 Chronicles 3:1 and in Genesis 22:2) is likely a mountain range, but won’t be essential to this study.

Since 2 Chronicles 3:1 specifically states that Solomon’s Temple was located in Jerusalem, and the Temple was to be built upon the threshing floor of Ornan the Jebusite, we know that the threshingfloor of Ornan the Jebusite must be in a specific spot within the city of Jerusalem.

Jerusalem at the time of David covered a very small area so the threshingfloor must have been located within that specific geographical area. Currently, the city of Jerusalem covers a much larger area. It is important not to commit the fallacy of superimposing what you see today over what existed at the specific time we are looking at. Even the topography of the land was significantly different at that time.

The story of David and the threshingfloor of Ornan the Jebusite is given in 1 Chronicles 21:18-30. Following the instructions that God commanded Gad to give him, David went to Ornan the Jebusite to build an altar to the LORD. Ornan wanted to give it to David, but David insisted on purchasing it. David built the altar there on the threshing floor. He could not offer sacrifices at the normal place, which was the altar of the burnt-offering in the tabernacle of the LORD located in “the high place at Gibeon” because he was afraid of the sword of the Angel of the Lord.

So three main facts have been established:

1. The Temple of Solomon was built within the geographical area covered by the city of Jerusalem at the time of David. It had to be within that area, or it would not have been in Jerusalem as is specifically stated.

2. The Temple was built on the threshingfloor of Ornan the Jebusite

3. The threshingfloor of Ornan the Jebusite was within the geographical area covered by the city of Jerusalem at the time of David. It could not have been outside the city of Jerusalem.

This may seem elementary, but it is important to keep these facts in mind at all times because the geographical area covered by the city of Jerusalem is essential to pinpointing the location of Solomon’s temple, and those that were built thereafter.

Jerusalem is the City of David

Jerusalem was originally occupied by the Jebusites—it was sometimes called Jebus, but was called Jerusalem a number of times. This is made clear by several verses—Joshua 15:8,63; 18:28; Judges 1:21; 19:10 and also 2 Samuel 5:6 which states:

And the king and his men went to Jerusalem unto the Jebusites, the inhabitants of the land: which spake unto David, saying, Except thou take away the blind and the lame, thou shalt not come in hither: thinking, David cannot come in hither.

But David “took the strong hold of Zion” i.e. the fortress (v7) by going up a watershaft from the Gihon Spring. David then lived in the fortress and called it “The City of David.” (v9). The Israelites could not drive the Jebusites out, so they lived with them until at least the time of the writing of Joshua and Judges. [Joshua 15:63 and Judges 1:21].

This event occurred sometime before David purchased the threshingfield from Ornan the Jebusite which was discussed earlier. So the geographical parcel of land which was Jerusalem at that time was also the exact location of the city of David because they were synonymous.

According to most any reference material out there, the Jebusite city called Jerusalem and also called the City of David, was a relatively small parcel of land, and the borders seem to be agreed upon by most of them. You can see an example map here: Map of Jebus or Jerusalem.  [Look at the third image from the top]

[Warning: Do not take the labeling on any map of the Jerusalem area for granted. Many of the labels are wrong, which will be shown in a future post. However, the basic geographical borders of the Jebusite City/The City of David is virtually identical on most maps.]

So now we know that Solomon’s temple had to be built within the City of Jerusalem/City of David specifically in the spot where Ornan the Jebusite’s threshingfloor was at the time of David. Any area outside of that place cannot be the location of any future temple either. The temple cannot be outside of the geographical area occupied by Jerusalem/City of David at the time of David.

The current area called “The Temple Mount” is OUTSIDE of that geographical area, so the temple could not have been located anywhere on it, unless you go against scripture.

[As always, I welcome comments and questions on this topic. Please keep them short and concise.]

Next:  The Biblical Case for the Location of the Temple Part 2

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave




Straight from the Healing Rooms Manual

Imagine being told that the root cause of your child’s Cystic Fibrosis is fear and anxiety?  Or, that you have Parkinson’s because you have unresolved rejection, self-rejection, or abandonment issues? Or, your parent has Alzheimers because of self-hatred, self-rejection, shame and guilt?

These are the kinds of things you will find in the official Healing Rooms Manual published by the International Association of Healing Rooms founded by Cal Pierce in 1999 whose headquarters is in Spokane, Washington.

On the second page of the Manual (no page numbers are given in the manual), it states:

Information for this book has been gathered through many thousands of prayer sessions in the Spokane Healing Rooms.  Scriptures are given on each disease as the Holy Spirit directed our team to them.

Root causes to sickness have been known by the medical industry for decades.  We have identified spiritual root causes by interviewing those prayed for.  Certain symptoms of sickness have similar root causes.  We simply have linked those which are most common root causes to specific diseases.  Our goal is to bring an awareness of what those root causes are and how to minister healing. [emphasis mine].

There are indeed demonstrable natural root causes to many sicknesses, however, this isn’t the same as assigning a spiritual root cause.  Furthermore, just because common issues appear regularly with a specific illness doesn’t mean it is the cause of the illness.  Correlation NEVER proves Causation. Just because the Sun comes up around the time a Rooster crows doesn’t mean the Rooster caused the Sun to come up.

For example, the root cause given for Cystic Fibrosis is “fear and anxiety.”  Online, there is an article that indicates fear and anxiety is common among those afflicted with the disease or those who care for them.  Due to the nature of the disease it is natural that it would cause this.  So, there is a correlation, but any reasonable person would realize that dealing with the disease is the cause of the fear and anxiety, not the other way around.

Some of the other Disease and Root Causes listed are:

Arthritis:  Usually involves bitterness from unforgiveness toward others or yourself
Autism:  Can be Generational.*  Rejection, rebellion, anger, self-hatred, spirit of fear, deaf and dumb spirit, and self-condemnation
Diabetes:  Extreme  rejection and self-hatred coupled with guilt.  Can be inherited through an unloving  spirit from parents or grandparents.  Could be a generational curse.
Hypoglycemia:  Worry, fear, fear of rejection, not trusting God, self-hatred; could be hereditary.
Stroke:   Could be generational.  Stress, anxiety, and anger.  Self-rejection, self-bitterness, self-hatred.
Varicose Veins:  Internalization of hurts that are caused by anger and resentment.  Usually inherited.

Root causes for different types of Cancer:

Cancer:  Can be deeply rooted bitterness, anger, guilt, and self-hatred.  Can be generational.
Colon Cancer:  Bitterness, slander, possibly generational with division making—contention.
Liver Cancer:  Lusting after a female, mentally or actually.  Often involving pornography, fornication, drugs and/or alcohol addiction.  Also bitterness.
Breast Cancer:  Conflict and bitterness between the female and her mother, sisters, or mother-in-law.
Ovarian Cancer:  Woman’s hatred for self and her sexuality and self-bitterness
Uterine Cancer:  Bitterness and self-bitterness; promiscuity and uncleanness
Hodgkin’s Disease & Leukemia:  Deep rooted bitterness coming from unresolved rejection by a father
Prostrate:  Bitterness, unforgiveness toward males in the family, fornication, fear.

*In the ministry sections for the disease it indicates that what is meant by “generational” is a generational curse.  On rare occasions the root cause is given as possibly inherited or genetic related.

After the section on the diseases, there is an article called “How to Keep Your Healing.”  It uses the parable of the sower in Matthew 13 out of context to support the belief that you can lose your healing.

When we receive a word on healing and are prayed for and a healing takes place, we receive it with joy but it must become firmly rooted in us because the devil will always try to inflict us with the very same symptoms to change our minds. Verse 21 says because of the Word, this affliction will be brought against us once again to cause us to fall away.

However, if you read the parable in context and take into consideration Jesus’ interpretation of it, this parable cannot be applied in the manner they have done. Nothing is referred to as a word on healing. It is actually the “word of the Kingdom.”  Verse 21 doesn’t say anything about an affliction being brought against us once again to cause us to fall away.  This is talking about troubles and tribulation in a person’s life.

The article in the Healing Manual goes on to state:

If the devil can cause us to look at symptoms instead of God’s promise, he can convince us to believe his lie.  When we focus on the symptoms, pain or whatever it is, doubt and unbelief come to our mind and this gives entrance for fear to re-establish the sickness.  We must keep our heart and mind fixed upon God and His promise…We need to hold fast to that which is good.  We must allow the Word to take root so that it can complete the manifestation of healing.

There is no description of anyone losing their healing anywhere in the entire Bible.  When Scripture describes divine healing it is always immediate and permanent and any visible symptoms disappear.

  1. Some were healed without exhibiting any faith at all.
  2. Some were healed through the faith of others
  3. Some were healed through their own faith
  4. Some were not healed because of an overall lack of faith in the area (not a specific person’s)
  5. 100% were healed immediately or within moments—never over a long period of time
  6. Absolutely NO ONE lost their healing

It is important to realize that a number of people in the New Testament were healed without any faith at all. The people at the Healing Rooms believe they have the gift of healing.  If this is true and they believe everyone is guaranteed healing, then if the person they pray for is not healed, logically it would be their own lack of faith, not the faith of the person they are praying for.  The belief that you can lose your healing appears to be a cop out—so that if the person isn’t healed, they can blame it on the person’s lack of faith.

In the Bible, how did the person being healed, the Apostles or the people watching know that the person was healed?  The SYMPTOMS disappeared!  The blind man could see, the lame could walk, the leper’s flesh became normal.  If you still have the symptoms, you are not healed.  These healings were also verified by the methods described in the Old Testament, by those with the expertise and authority to declare that the person was healed.  If the person still had the symptoms, they would not have been declared healed or “clean.”

For more detailed, in-depth discussion of this topic, please watch the presentation on this question “Can a Person Lose their Healing?

The Healing Rooms Manual has a number of concerning issues and should make a person think twice about going to one for healing.

 




Do They Really Teach That?

It is well known that New “Age” Spirituality teaches the pantheistic view that we are all God.  However, you would be surprised by who else teaches this.

Though hidden in the massive text of the Catechism, the Roman Catholic Church teaches that we can become God or gods:

The Word became flesh to make us “partakers of the divine nature”:  “For this is why the Word became man, and the Son of God became the Son of man: so that man, by entering into communion with the Word and thus receiving divine sonship, might become a son of God” “For the Son of God became man so that we might become God.” “The only-begotten Son of God, wanting to make us sharers in his divinity, assumed our nature, so that he, made man, might make men gods. (460) [emphasis mine]

This paragraph is made up of several quotations.  In the footnotes, it shows 2 Peter 1:4 as the reference for the first statement.

Whereby are given unto us exceeding great and precious promises:  that by these ye might be partakers of the divine nature, having escaped the corruption that is in the world through lust. [KJV]

This verse is used by other groups to teach that man can become God.  However, this is twisting the verse to say something that it doesn’t.  The Greek word translated “partake” may be familiar to you.  It is “koinonos” and it means “a partner, associate, comrade, or companion.”  It is translated as “partake or partaker” in four other Scripture passages, and it never means that they become what they are partaking of.

Matt. 23:30  “…partakers with them in the blood of the prophets.”
1 Cor. 10:18 “…are they which eat of the sacrifices partakers of the altar?”
2 Cor. 1:7 “…as ye are partakers of the sufferings…”
1 Peter 5:1 “…and also a partaker of the glory that shall be revealed.”

The partakers in Matthew—did not become the blood of the prophets.  The partakers of the altar—did not become the altar.  The partakers of the sufferings—did not become sufferings.  The partakers of the glory—did not become the glory.  To partake of something, never means to become what you are partaking of.

The second quotation from the Catechism is from St. Irenaeus:

“For this is why the Word became man, and the Son of God became the Son of man: so that man, by entering into communion with the Word and thus receiving divine sonship, might become a son of God”

There is nothing wrong with this statement, because believers do become sons of God.  However, it does nothing to support the other statements.

The third quotation is given as from St. Athanasius in De Incarnatione:

“For the Son of God became man so that we might become God.”

The fourth quotation is from St. Thomas Aquinus:

“The only-begotten Son of God, wanting to make us sharers in his divinity, assumed our nature, so that he, made man, might make men gods.”

It is quite possible that these are being taken out of context and their translation into English may be faulty, but there is no explanation in the Catechism to indicate anything different, and it has never been modified since first published, so we have no choice but to take it at its word—the Catechism teaches man can become gods or God.




Rapture Question #3: How is the Rapture a “Mystery”?

Recommended:  Rapture Question #1: Is the word “Rapture” found in the Bible?

The previous article Rapture Question #2: What Does the Term “In Christ” Mean?” pointed out that Post-Tribulation proponents believe that since the 1 Thessalonians passage describes the resurrection of the dead, this must be referring to the resurrection which occurs at the 2nd Coming.  The first issue with this view is that only the dead “in Christ” are resurrected and this term only refers to members of the Body of Christ.

A second issue with believing this to be the resurrection at the 2nd Coming is regarding the word “mystery” being used in 1 Corinthians 15:51-52. The English word “Mystery” is translated from the Greek word mystērion μυστήριον.  It is a secret that hitherto has not been revealed.

What is the Biblical Definition of a Mystery?

In Colossians 1:26 Paul indicates that a “mystery” is something that had been hidden from past generations, but is later revealed to the saints.

In a similar way, Paul explains in Epheisans 3:2-6 that the “mystery” that “the Gentiles should be fellow heirs, and of the same body, and partakers of his promise in Christ by the gospel” was revealed to him by Jesus who “made known unto me the mystery (as I wrote afore in few words, whereby, when ye read, ye may understand my knowledge in the mystery of Christ) Which in other ages was not made known unto the sons of men, as it is NOW revealed unto his holy apostles and prophets by the Spirit.”

In 1 Corinthians 15:51-52 Paul then reveals another “mystery” when he states: Behold, I shew you a mystery; We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trump: for the trumpet shall sound, and the dead shall be raised incorruptible, and we shall be changed.”1

Was the Coming of the Lord Revealed in the Old Testament?

This event (the Rapture of the Church) was unknown until Paul revealed it to the Church by revelation directly from Jesus Christ. This is very important, because the 2nd Coming and the resurrection of the just and the unjust were clearly discussed in the Old Testament.

In Daniel 7:13-14, Daniel states “I saw in the night visions, and behold, one like the Son of man came with the clouds of heaven, and came to the Ancient of days, and they brought him near before him. And there was given him dominion, and glory, and a kingdom, that all people nations, and languages, should serve him: his dominion is an everlasting dominion, which shall not pass away, and his kingdom that which shall not be destroyed.”

Zechariah describes the coming of the Lord in Zechariah 14:4-5 in which He stands on the Mount of Olives and it divides in two.  In verse 5 it states “…and the Lord my God shall come, and all the saints with him.”

Daniel 12:2 describes the resurrection that will occur at the “end of days.” And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contemptv13 But go thou thy way till the end be: for thou shalt rest, and stand in thy lot at the end of days.”

So the “Mystery” that Paul revealed in 1 Corinthians 15:51-52 could NOT be referring to the resurrection that occurs at the 2nd Coming because the 2nd Coming was clearly described BEFORE the Church even came into existence, and therefore, wasn’t an undisclosed mystery.

__________________________

Notes

1Even though Paul doesn’t specifically state the dead “in Christ” in this passage, at the beginning of this Epistle to the Corinthians, he indicates that he is writing it to “the Church of God which is at Corinth with all the saints which are in Achaia.”  He is writing to the believers who by definition are “in Christ.”

Next:  The Rapture Question #4: Is the Rapture Imminent?




Rapture Question #2: What Does the Term “In Christ” Mean?

Recommended: Rapture Question #1: Is the word “Rapture” found in the Bible.

One of the main arguments put forth to support a Post-Tribulation Rapture is 1 Thessalonians 4:13-18 where it is asserted that since the dead are being raised this must be the Resurrection which happens at the 2nd Coming of Christ.  However, they ignore one very important detail—not all of the dead will be raised at the Rapture.  Paul makes a point of indicating that it is only the dead IN CHRIST who are being raised at this time.

For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first.” 1 Corinthians 15:18 also describes believers who have died as those which are “fallen asleep in Christ.

Who are the Dead “in Christ”?

The term “In Christ” is used numerous times in the New Testament where it refers to believers who make up the Body of Christ, the “Church” the Ekklesia of Christ.

2 Corinthians 5:17 describes what happens when a person becomes a believer– Therefore if any man be in Christ, he is a new creature; old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new.” 

Romans 12:5 declares So we being many are one body in Christ, and every one members one of another.

Another passage where this is shown is in Romans 16:7 which states, “Salute Andronicus and Junia, my kinsmen, and my fellow prisoners, who are of note among the apostles, who also were in Christ before me.”  Paul indicates here that Andronicus and Junia were “in Christ” before he was, meaning that they were believers before Paul became a believer.

Other references to check out are:

Romans 8:1; Romans 16:3, 9; 1 Corinthians 3:1; 2 Corinthians 12:2; Galatians 1:22; Galatians 3:28; Philippians 1:1; Philippians 4:21; Colossians 1:2; 1 Thessalonians 2:14; 1 Peter 5:14; Philemon 1:23 and Philippians 4:21.

When did the Church begin?

In Matthew 17:18, Jesus statesUpon this rock (himself, the cornerstone) I WILL build my Ekklesia (Church).”  “I WILL build” is translated from the Greek word οἰκοδομήσω which is in the Future Tense.

The most important part of the Greek verb is the ending of the verb which tells us more than one thing. What is important in this instance is the sigma σ.  This is called a tense formative.  The sigma is the tense formative that tells us the verb is in the future tense.  At the time Jesus spoke these words, what he was speaking of was still something that would happen in the future.  The Ekklesia could not have existed before this.  Future means future.

In 1 Corinthians 12:13, Paul describes the means by which we enter into the Body of Christ.  “For by one Spirit are we all baptized into one body, whether we be Jews or Gentiles, whether we be bond or free; and have been all made to drink into one Spirit.

So, when did this happen?  The matter of when the Church began rests squarely on when the first believers were baptized into the Body of Christ.  The Church could not have existed until this began to occur.

In Acts 1:5 just before ascending into Heaven, Jesus states For John truly baptized with water; but ye shall be baptized with the Holy Ghost not many days hence.”  So even at the time of the ascension, the Church had not yet begun.

Just as Jesus stated, a short time later in Acts 2 a total of 120 people (including the 12 Apostles, Mary the Mother of Jesus, the brothers of Jesus and other un-named women) were in the Upper Room on the day of Pentecost when they were all filled with the Holy Ghost just as Jesus had promised.

When is the Church complete?

In Romans 11:25 Paul tells the Roman believers, For I would not, brethren, that ye should be ignorant of this mystery, lest ye should be wise in your own conceits; that blindness in part is happened to Israel, until the fulness of the Gentiles be come in.” The church will continue until the final believer has become a part of the body of Christ.  The Rapture of the Body of Christ will occur when the Body of Christ is complete.  Then soon after that, the partial blindness of Israel will be removed.

The Old Testament saints are not included in the Rapture because they are not part of the Body of Christ, they are not “in Christ.”  They are resurrected at the 2nd Coming of Christ along with those who become believers AFTER the Rapture occurs (which are often called “tribulation saints”) and before the 2nd Coming of Christ.

(For more information on the identity of the Church, please see “The Church in the Wilderness.“)

Next:  The Rapture Question #3: How is the Rapture a “Mystery?”




How Can a Believer Avoid Being Deceived?

Wouldn’t it be great if there was a vaccination against being deceived?  Well, there is!  It is what used to be, as a matter of course, taught to all new believers right after they accepted Christ.  They would be handed a Bible and given the instructions to—

  1. Read, Study and Meditate on the Word of God every day
  2. Pray every day

The true method of Bible study, meditation and prayer comes from the Bible itself. Once you have this foundation, should you hear a fancy name for “prayer” such as Centering Prayer, Contemplative Prayer, Soaking Prayer, Lectio Divina, Breath Prayers, etc. you can be confident it’s not Biblical prayer, or it wouldn’t need a fancy name in the first place!

Also, be aware that not only are these “methods” not Biblical prayer, they aren’t actually “prayer” at all, but Mystical Meditation techniques—which are definitely NOT Biblical Meditation. (See: Is Contemplative Prayer, Biblical Prayer?)

Search the Scriptures

It is essential that you never just believe what a Bible teacher or a Pastor teaches, no matter how much you trust them, or how popular or famous they are, but that you verify it for yourself by searching the Word of God.

Acts 17:11 is a well-known, and often used, passage regarding the Bereans who searched the Scriptures to see if what Paul and Silas were teaching them was the truth.

These (The Bereans) were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so.”

The question becomes, what does it really mean to “search” the Scriptures?  Many people think that it simply means to go to the Scripture passages and read them, but if that were true, deception wouldn’t be much of an issue.

The Greek word translated “searched” in this passage is “anakrinō” ἀνακρίνω.  According to the Blue Letter Bible and Thayer’s Lexicon, it means “to examine or judge.”  More specifically, “to investigate, examine, enquire into, scrutinize, sift, and question.” This often requires more effort than many believers are willing to put into investigating the matter themselves.

In 2 Timothy 2:15 Paul states Study to show thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.”  Hermeneutics is a fancy name for methods of interpreting Scripture to assist us in “rightly dividing the word of truth.”

The ultimate goal is to determine the original writer’s intended meaning of a Scripture passage. This is called “Exegesis (ek-si-jee-sis) which is attempting to “pull out” of the passage the actual intended meaning.  What we don’t want to do is Eisegesis (ayh-si-jee-sis), which is the opposite of exegesis.  It is “reading into” a particular text a person’s own ideas and interpretation of Scriptures that are not indicated by the text itself.

There are three main steps to thoroughly study Scripture (often referred to as the Historical-Grammatical Method of Interpretation):

  • Conducting Word Studies:  (The meaning of the word in the original language)
  • Analyzing the Thought Structure: (The relationships of the words—Grammar and Syntax)
  • Studying the Context and Co-text:  (Immediate context and considering the “whole counsel of God”)

Once we have determined the actual, intended meaning of the Scripture passage, we may be able to apply it directly to our lives, if appropriate, or indirectly by gleaning a principle from the passage.  Or, it may have simply clarified a specific doctrine or event.

Avoid and watch for Divination (Bibliomancy)

There is an old joke that shows an exaggerated example of using the Bible as a divination tool:

A man needed guidance from God on what he should do regarding a certain situation in his life, so he took his Bible and let it fall open randomly.  He closed his eyes and pointed his finger at the page.  When he opened his eyes, he found that his finger was on the Scripture passage which said “Judas went out and hung himself.”  The man thought, well, that doesn’t really apply to me or my situation, I better try again, so he did it the second time and he read “Go thou and do likewise.”

My first introduction to “divination” from Scripture was when I was around 10 years old or so. I saw a book by Oral Roberts, and out of curiosity, I flipped through the pages until I happened upon a statement where Oral Roberts stated something like “God tells us in the Bible that he wants us to ‘prosper and be in good health.’ ”  Then I read the Scripture verse he was quoting and thought “Well, that’s stupid.  God didn’t say that, it’s John speaking to some guy named Gaius.  He’s just telling his friend that he hopes that he will “prosper and be in good health.”  (3 John 1:1-2)

Most believers don’t do this as blatantly as the above examples (at least I hope not).  However, there is a more subtle version that occurs quite frequently.  An example of this occurs in the book “Preparing the Way.”

In one instance the author, Cal Pierce, points out an Old Testament story where Isaac “re-dug” the wells that his father had previously dug.  This is simply a historical narrative describing what occurred. But Cal takes this as God telling him personally that he should, in a figurative sense, “re-dig” the wells of healing that John G. Lake had originally dug.  This is not something anyone would understand from simply reading this passage.  He has used the Bible as a divination tool to show him a special message from God meant only for him.

To allegorize or spiritualize Scripture is another method of Eisegesis.  Allegorical interpretation is counter-intuitive, meaning, it is contrary to what one would normally expect.  It assigns whatever meaning the interpreter chooses, using whatever rules he has predetermined.  It sounds similar to “divination.”  However, in this case, it is something that supposedly applies to everyone.

Extreme deception in the last days is already prevalent, now more than ever we need to be vigilant in “rightly dividing the word of truth” and testing any teaching against Scripture itself.  It is our immunization against deception.




Touch Not God’s Anointed?

Should we disclose the names of false teachers and point out their false teaching?  Many say, “no.” They try to support this by taking two teachings of scripture out of context—confronting a brother in private and “touch not God’s anointed.”

Go to Your Brother in Private

Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone: if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother. But if he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or two more, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established. And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as a heathen man and a publican.” [KJV]

Matthew 18:15-17 (above) is often misapplied as a command to go to a false teacher to confront him in private before refuting his false teaching publicly. [Hello? Where does it say that?]

However, that IS NOT what this passage teaches, it states “if thy brother shall trespass against thee.” This tresspass or sin is against you personally. Jesus is giving instructions on how to handle a specific situation, that of your brother personally sinning against you.

There is nothing in the context of this passage that indicates it applies to confronting false teachers and false teaching. No scripture passage instructs us to go to the false teacher in private. As a side note, Jesus said this before the Church existed, so whatever this assembly or congregation was, it was not the Church. [see “The Church in the Wilderness.”]

So, Matthew 18:15-17 does not apply to refuting false teachers and false teaching.

Touch not God’s anointed!

Others will say, we should not name names or criticize their teachings because they are God’s anointed. This is taken from the passage in Psalms 105:8-15 which states in verse 15: “Touch not mine anointed, and do my prophets no harm.” [KJV]

In this passage, God was telling the nations to not “physically touch” His anointed (Israel) or His prophets. In other passages, “the Lord’s anointed” was in reference to the kings of the nation of Israel as it is in 1 Sam. 16:6,13. The Hebrew verb translated as “touch” is “naga” and refers to physically touching or striking. (Mounce 737)

In 1 Samuel 24:10-11 the Lord gives Saul into the hands of David when he finds Saul sleeping in a cave. But David refuses to “touch God’s anointed” and spares his life, only cutting a piece out of Saul’s garment. In verse ten David declares to Saul, “Behold, this day thine eyes have seen how that the LORD had delivered thee today into mine hand in the cave: and some bade me kill thee: but mine eye spared thee; and I said, I will not put forth mine hand against my lord, for he is the LORD’s anointed.”

David is stating here that he would not kill or physically harm Saul who is God’s anointed.

This is also begs the question—how can a false teacher be God’s anointed? Isn’t that an oxymoron?

Should we Name Names?

Whenever a person (i.e., Bible teacher, pastor, evangelist, spiritual leader, guru, etc.) publishes his or her teaching in an article, book, DVD, or other media format and distributes it, the content of such published work is now open to scrutiny, discussion, and debate. The published work and the name of the author should be included in that discussion. If the author is not willing to have his or her teaching scrutinized in this fashion, then the author should not publish his or her work.

However, this discussion and debate should never include any personal attacks of any kind. We cannot judge the intents of the heart or the sincerity of the teacher. Only God can make that kind of judgment. You are judging the teaching, not the person. Objective discussions should be executed in a logical fashion, backed up with the truth of God’s Word, and supported with documented facts.

I expect no less from anyone reading the information at Analytical Faith. Don’t believe anything I have said, but search the Scriptures and judge all things as the Scripture commands. (Acts 17:11)

Notes:

Mounce, William D. Mounce’s Complete Expository dictionary of Old & New Testament Words. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2006. Print.




Book Review: Preparing the Way—The Reopening of the John G. Lake Healing Rooms in Spokane, Washington

In his book “Preparing the Way,” Cal Pierce, the Founder and Director of the Healing Rooms International, gives his autobiographical story of how the Healing Rooms began.  He describes a series of “meant to be” amazing “coincidences” and a number of prophecies that directed him to “re-dig the wells of healing” that John G. Lake, a famous “healer,” had started in the early 1900’s.    He gets so caught up in these experiences that he doesn’t seem to give any thought to testing the spirits like we are instructed to do in 1 John 4:1. These amazing “meant to be” experiences become a theme throughout his entire book.

If you have read any of former New Ager Warren Smith’s books or heard his testimony, you will understand how these types of “meant to be” experiences are very common in New “Age” Spirituality. Satan is capable of orchestrating these “meant to be” experiences.  So these amazing coincidences can’t be automatically assumed to be from God.  It is essential to test these experiences against  Scripture.

Cal states that after many years of attending church and being a self-described “bored” member, something happened that changed his life forever.  One night in 1996, a couple from his RV group told him what was happening in some meetings that his new pastor Bill Johnson and a Vineyard pastor were conducting in the area churches.  People were “falling down, laughing, shaking, and crying.” (Pierce 33)

After a short discussion, he and his wife decided they wouldn’t be attending those meetings.  But by May of that year, Pastor Johnson called for a special meeting for all of the leadership of the church.  Although Cal wasn’t happy about it, he was required to go since he was a member of the board.

At the meeting, after they had sung several  worship choruses, Pastor Johnson stood up and raised his hands to Heaven and said “Come Holy Spirit!.”

“The next thing I remember,” Cal states, “is that wave after wave of fire began to course through my body.  The flames seemed to be going deep into my bones and that made me want to run or jump or shout or scream or all of those things at once.  But I couldn’t move.  My feet were stuck to the floor, as if they had been glued there.

Within what seemed like a few minutes, I heard Michelle’s [his wife] voice.  She was pulling on my sleeve, trying to get my attention.  ‘Honey’ she was saying ‘the meeting’s over, and everyone’s gone home.’  I had no idea what the meeting had been about, but I somehow knew that I would never be the same again.

I tried to move again, but couldn’t.  It took two strong men to pull me loose from the floor that night, and from then on the change in my life was so great that it was like the difference between night and day.” (pg 34)

This experience isn’t something that can be confirmed by Scripture.  Something to keep in mind is that in Paul’s discussion of the Gifts of the Spirit in 1 Corinthians 14:32, he makes it clear that the “spirits of the prophets are subject to the prophet.”  The Holy Spirit never takes control over our body so that we become powerless to control anything that we are doing.  Not being able to move or do anything for a period of time would not be caused by the work of the Holy Spirit.  It would contradict clear teaching in Scripture.

Cal goes on to state that somehow the old Cal Pierce had died that night and “all of his plans and desires died with him. (pg 35)  He suddenly had an inexhaustible desire to study everything he could get his hands on about spiritual growth and especially regarding “revival” and healing.  [Nothing about studying the Word of God?]

Cal’s wife, Michelle, hadn’t become involved in everything that he had.  She didn’t outright oppose what he was doing, but she wasn’t too excited about it either.  He states:  “I could sense her reservations when I announced to her one day that we would have to scrap all of our plans for the future.  There would be no early retirement and no “RV”ing.  That lifestyle no longer interested me in the least.”

So, he didn’t expect her to understand when he announced his decision to take a trip up North for a few days.  For reasons that he indicated were not totally clear to him, he decided to take a trip to Spokane, Washington.

When he announced in his Sunday School class where he was planning to go, one of the ladies spoke up.  She said that she had recently read a book by Ken and Gloria Copeland about John G. Lake, and that he was from Spokane and was also buried there.  Cal then realized that months earlier he had read the same book, but had forgotten about it.

Driving the 10-12 hour drive from Redding to Spokane, he couldn’t get the thought out of his mind that he was “going to the city where John G. Lake had been used so mightily by God.” (pg 47)   He remembered that John G. Lake had “experienced a hundred thousand documented healings in only five years of ministry, and this resulted in Spokane being officially declared the healthiest city in the world.” (pg 47)

[NOTE: This is stated in numerous sources on the internet and in books, but to my knowledge, so far no actual documentation has ever been given for these healings nor has a copy of the official statement been produced.]

Cal planned to do a number of things while in Spokane.  He wanted to see the building where the miracles happened; he wanted to see the tabernacle where John G. Lake had ministered; and he wanted to see the home where he lived.  He also wanted to see his grave, and decided to start there first.

Once he arrived in Spokane, he stopped at a convenience store and bought a map to see where the cemeteries were located.  He found that there were three large ones and many little ones.  He decided to just pick one, and you guessed it, he picked the right cemetery on the first try.  At the cemetery’s visitor center, he asked for the location of John G. Lake’s grave and was told that his was the most visited of any grave site in the city.

Once he found the grave, he laid down on it and began to cry out to God.  “God, bring up the anointing of this man to me.  Let it rise out of his bones.  I want to walk in the same power that he walked in.  I want to see the miracles that he saw. (pgs 48-49)

[NOTE: This is something called “grave soaking” and is practiced by the youth from Bethel Church where Cal Pierce came from and whose pastor is Bill Johnson.]

After visiting John G. Lake’s home and tabernacle, Cal went to the location of the old Rookery Building where John G. Lake’s healing rooms had been located.  The original building had burnt down, but had been rebuilt.  He went up to the third floor where he remembered the healing rooms were originally located.  He spent quite a while praying as he walked up and down the hallways.  He states:  “The enemy was there too.  He said to me ‘What are you doing here?  You’re no John G. Lake.’  I knew that was true so I went back out to the grave site to pray some more. (pg 50)  He spent three more days in Spokane praying and then went home.

After several more trips to Spokane, Cal and his wife moved to Spokane.   Cal indicates that they weren’t sure why God had sent them there, but they were determined to find out.  For a year and three months Cal continued to visit the grave of John G. Lake once a month.  He and his wife tried out a number of churches.  In each church they visited, they asked people if they knew about John G. Lake.  Cal claims that many had heard of him and that they all had been praying that the same anointing and healing would come to Spokane.

Cal was certain that God had brought them to Spokane for a purpose, and finally he felt prompted to do a 40 day fast.  During his fast, he claims that the Holy Spirit led him to a passage in Genesis regarding Isaac and how he re-dug the wells that belonged to his father Abraham, and that he renamed them the same names they had before.  The wells were then restored.  Cal believed that this meant he was supposed to “re-dig the wells of healing.”

His book then flashes back to describe how others had “prepared the way” for the healing rooms.  The “meant to be” experiences then go into faster-than-light speed.

Others Prepare the Way?

In August of 1996, two men by the name of Timothy Johnson and Tom Bensen attended a meeting in Spokane conducted by a “prophet” named  Bob Jones, (pg 65) who had prophesied that a new healing anointing would begin outside of the City of Spokane, it would be brought into Spokane and then it would finally go out into the whole world.

So Tim and Tom came to Spokane to prepare for it.  Over a period of 18 months they made a number of trips to Spokane.  They too were “led” to the grave of John G. Lake to pray and to the site of the Rookery Building.  They also conducted several 40-day fasts during that time. They claimed that the Holy Spirit had told them that he was sending them there to “prepare the way for healing.”

After seeing a brochure that Cal had sent out, Tim called Cal and told him he had heard about what he was doing.  Cal states “This was amazing.  These men didn’t know us, and we didn’t know them, yet God had dealt with each of us separately concerning the exact same burden.” (pg 67)

Tim then told Cal that Bob Jones said that while he was preparing for meetings in Spokane, he could see in the spirit realm “a huge python over the city.  He was given the authority to strike the Python behind its head with a sword, but he couldn’t kill it.  The Lord told him that the local church would have to do that.  He then struck it in its reproductive organs so that it could not reproduce before the church got united enough to kill it.” (pg 67)

He also saw an angel that God sent over the area who was tattered because of an intense battle between him and the demonic forces.  Bob Jones declared “God’s people needed to unite in intercession, so that no more angelic forces would be sent to the area. (pg 67)

Tim goes on to state that after the conference before he went home, he was led to go to the grave site of John G. Lake to pray.  He claims that “the Lord spoke to me and said ‘I will restore the healing anointing that was on John G. Lake.  It will start in Spokane and spread like wildfire across America from here.  Revival in the Northwest will also begin in Spokane.’  I sensed that the roots of the huge pine tree over the grave were flowing down into the bones of the man of God and bringing up strength for a new generation of healing ministries.” (pg 68)

Then, Tim said that he was blown away when he heard that Bob Jones was also led by the Lord to go to the grave of John G. Lake and pray.  He (Bob Jones) too stated that the Lord had revealed to him that “the tree growing down into the grave was a prophetic sign from God that He would revive the anointing that had been over his servant. (pg 68)

Tim asked God if it was time for them to go to the city, and He said that it was.  Tim asked Tom to go with him.  They decided to pray about it and if God confirmed it they would go the following Saturday.

Tom started praying and he claims the Holy Spirit instructed him to “Go into the garage and get the staff  you cut in the Redwood forest…bring it into the house and write on it ‘My Name is Elohim.’” (pg 69)  Tom followed the instructions and then called Tim who amazingly was sitting at his own kitchen table with a staff that he had just finished writing the names of God on.

They took the staffs with them on their trip to Spokane.  They went to the Rookery building and walked around the area praying.  They claim that as they passed through a food court on the other side of the street, they ran into a demonic force that almost knocked them down.  Tim states “I seemed to be suddenly overtaken by a magnetic field, and I had the feeling of static electricity around my body.” (pgs 69-70)  Tom felt it also and asked Tim “What is this?

After walking to another part of town, they came back to the same area and felt the same thing they had before.  Tom believed that they had encountered a prince of demons over the city who seemed to be boasting “This is my city and I will not be brought down.” (pg 70)


Medical Lake Healing Water?

On New Year’s Eve of 1997, Tom and his wife invited some “prophetically gifted” friends to their house for prayer.  After their prayer time, Tim slept over at his house.  The next morning, Tom and Tim were discussing a dream that Tom had concerning the coming revival in Spokane.  Tom states that he heard over and over again a word from the Lord about “a lake of medicine.” (pg 70)

The two of them got out a map of Spokane to look for anything like that. They couldn’t find anything, but when Tom’s wife, Betty, found a better map, they were amazed to discover that just outside of Spokane there was a small town called Medical Lake.   Tom states “We wondered if this is what Bob Jones’ prophecy had meant  that the revival of healing would start outside of Spokane?  Would it come from Medical Lake? (pgs 70-71)

They looked it up on the computer and found that

“Medical Lake was also the name of a small town, five* miles outside of Spokane, on the shores of Medical Lake.  The lake was discovered by a French Canadian sheep herder by the name of Lefevre.  In the early 1800’s**, he had gone to the lake one day to bathe and was immediately*** healed of his advanced rheumatoid arthritis.  He had named the lake in French, and his name translated to Medical Lake.

Local Indians had also discovered the medicinal and curative powers of the water of Medical Lake.  They had built steam baths around the lake where they poured the water over the hot rocks and breathed in the resulting steam.  They also claimed many healings from its use.

The water of the Medical Lake was found to be high in mineral content, so that when it was boiled down, it left a salty residue.  The Indians carried these salts to distant tribes who could not reach the lake and many of them likewise claimed healing from the use of salts.” (pg 71)

*Actually it is 15 miles not 5
**Actually it was the late 1800’s
***Records say “was almost completely healed”

This is where they stop regarding the history of the lake.  The moment I saw the name Medical Lake in Cal’s book as I was reading it for the first time, I just about fell off of my chair.  My jaw dropped open, and I thought “You have GOT to be kidding?”

Medical Lake is my home town.  In 1972 when Medical Lake celebrated it’s 100 year anniversary, they put out a paper with a lot of information about the history of Medical Lake.  I was in 5th grade at the time and became very interest in it at that point.  I have read a lot about the history and have collected information regarding it over the years.

As I read the history that Tom was reciting, I noticed something very disturbing.  He stopped after delivering the information about the lake having natural healing powers.  As I read through the rest of the book and have also searched the Healing Room websites, there is absolutely NO information regarding what happened after that.  This is something that anyone can easily find by going to the Medical Lake website.

“From the 1880’s to to the early part of the century, Medical Lake remained a flourishing town and popular vacation destination, and boasted a growing community.  The lake, however, was dredged of most of its minerals deposits over the years and people began to wonder if the lake ever had the ability to heal its users.  The lake showed the effects of the adjacent land developments.  Algae blooms destroyed everything, except for the lake’s recreational value.” (History)

It goes on to state that in 1964, the City installed a sewer system.  The lake could not recover to its pristine state because the lake quality had been so severely degraded. It got so bad that fish could no longer survive in the lake. In 1977, the phosphorous levels were greatly reduced when treated with liquid alum.  Then in 1986 “an aerator was installed in the lake to increase oxygen levels and decrease algae blooms.” (History)  This improved the lake quality so that it could once again be used for recreational use.  The lake no longer has any natural healing properties.  It also should be noted that it NEVER had any SUPERnatural healing properties.

Why did they not fill us in with the rest of the details?  This becomes very misleading. Most people reading or hearing this information wouldn’t be the wiser.  It would be logical for them to conclude that the water STILL has healing properties.

Another issue is that this story written in the book about the circumstances surrounding the discovery of this information is significantly different in an audio presentation by Cal Pierce.   It is natural through each telling of a story to include some details that weren’t included before, or leaving out details that had been included at other times.  However, the story in the audio presentations gives an entirely different story that contradicts the details in this book. (Pierce, Audio file)

After the story of Medical Lake, Tim goes on to recount other stories to Cal.  “In April of that year the Lord impressed us again to undertake a long fast.  He was about to send us back to Spokane.” (pg 71)

Tim and Tom didn’t know what all they would be doing, but they felt that God was telling them to “speak a word of release” over the city.  They went to Spokane to end their most recent 40 day fast.  As they drove into the city, they noticed how many hospitals and clinics there were.  They observed that the city that (allegedly) had once been declared “the healthiest city in America” was now obviously a place of much sickness.  [NOTE:  Again, that declaration has never been documented to my knowledge.]

They were determined to find out more about the “demonic force” that they encountered on the previous visit.  When they approached the same food court again, they felt it as before.  So they went back to their hotel room and asked God what they were up against.

Tom found the story of David and Goliath in his Bible and read it out loud.  Then Tim said to read it again slowly.  The second time they both felt that Holy Spirit was telling them that “it was the spirit of Goliath that had spread intimidation over the city of Spokane and prevented the healing anointing from flowing back into it.” (pg 72)

A few minutes later they decided to go to the Mall.  On the way, they saw a billboard that said “Burger Hut:  Home of the Goliath Burger.”  They felt that this was God confirming what they had felt the Holy Spirit was telling them.

That night, God told them to go to the city of Medical Lake for the first time.  So they went there the next morning.  They “prayed around the lake” and were led to put their staffs into the lake water to “trouble” the water.  They were sure that as soon as they put their staffs in, there was a “stirring of the waters.”  Tom wept as the Lord “showed him that the healing water of the lake [The natural healing properties had been gone for a very long time] would not just be for Spokane, but for the healing of the nations.” (pg 73)

As a “prophetic act” they took five gallons of water from the lake and then poured it into the Spokane River where the river would carry it into the cityAs they poured the water into the river, “Tom was overcome with emotion and declared This Healing will flow to all the nations of the Earth.’” (pg 73)

While they were eating at a restaurant that evening, they sensed that they had one more thing they needed to do– “Prophesy to the giant spirit over the City of Spokane the next day, and then we would be free to go home.” (pg 73)

Then they overheard some ladies at another table speaking about some local meetings.  They spoke to them and found out that they were Spirit-filled Catholics.  Tim and Tom had heard of Spirit-filled Catholics, but had never met any before.

The ladies said that they were from Montana and had come to Spokane to attend a healing conference at Gonzaga University, and this was to be the final night of the conference where there would be “a special prayer for anointing and healing.”

Tim and Tom decided to go.  At the end of the service, they lined up with others who were waiting to be anointed by the priests.  “As they laid hands on all of us, people went down under the power of God in every direction.  There were bodies covering the entire floor of the auditorium.  Tom and I were drunk in the Spirit and felt ready for our most important work the following morning.” (pg 74)

There is nothing in Scripture that describes this phenomenon.  Even at Pentecost, there is no description of people being “slain in the Spirit” and covering the entire floor of the Upper Room.  If it were going to happen, you certainly would expect it would have happened then.

The next morning, Tim and Tom parked at the old Rookery Building (where the original healing rooms of John G. Lake had been located).  They stood facing the building and with staffs in hand they “spoke forth the word of Lord against the enemy that bound the city.” (pg 75)  Then they struck their staffs seven times on the pavement.

As they were leaving, they saw a sign two blocks down that read “David’s Pizza”  They took that as confirmation from the Lord that the giant would fall.

Six months later, the Lord told them to go to the Catholic Church in Medical Lake.  They didn’t know if there was one there or not, but “something was troubling their spirits.”  They had begun another 40 day fast, and during that time Tom asked a friend if she knew anything about a Catholic Church in Medical Lake.  She found that not only was there a Catholic church there, but it held healing meetings twice a month.  Tim then called the church and asked when the next healing meeting would be conducted.  He was surprised to find out that the next one was going to occur on the fortieth day of their fast.

A few days before they went to Medical Lake for the healing meeting, Tim states that the Lord had given him a special verse and told him that it was for a Catholic priest at Medical Lake.  They had planned on first getting a room in Spokane before heading to Medical Lake for the meeting, but the Lord told Tim that he should go to Medical that night even though it was getting very late in the evening.  Tim claims he didn’t say anything about it to Tom, but that 20 minutes later, Tom said “I think the Lord is speaking to me about going to Medical Lake tonight.” (pg 76)

They arrived at Medical Lake at 9:30 p.m.  and found the Catholic Church.  Everything was dark, but they found an apartment attached to the building.  The priest, Father Tom Mele, answered the door.  Tim and Tom sat down with him and told him how they had been led to his front door.  After they told most of the story, they informed him that God had given a message to them for him.  After giving him the message, he got an amazed look on his face and went to another room, and when he came back he had a card in his hand.

Father Mele then said that this was the 20th anniversary of his ordination as a priest.  He had become a priest because of a promise that God gave him which he had written down on a postcard.  He handed the card to them and to their amazement it was the same verse that they had given him.

That night, they stayed in a motel closer to Medical Lake, and the next day they went into town.  It was the last day of their fast and Tim was hungry for a hamburger. They decided to go to the place that had the Goliath hamburgers.  Tim told Tom “I wouldn’t be surprised if “Goliath Burger” is shut down.”  As they were nearing the place, they couldn’t believe their eyes, “The concrete structure had been demolished, and all that was left was a pile of rubble.”  They claimed that God told them “What you see here in the natural is what took place in the Spirit.” (pg 78)

They then went back to the Rookery Building and found that the “horrible power” they had felt before was now gone.  Tom states “Because we couldn’t eat Goliath burgers to break our fast, we settled for David’s pizza instead.  It was delicious.” (pg 78)

[NOTE: Unless they were on just a partial fast, this would have made them very ill, you can’t go from eating nothing for days to eating a pizza, because the digestive system has shut down.]

At the meeting that night at the Catholic church in Medical Lake, they were given a copy of a book that had the 150 year history of the church.  A quote from a minister in the book stated that “Medical Lake in the state of Washington is a modern-day Pool of Bethesda.” (pg 35)

[NOTE:  Notice how it only says “a minister” this gives the impression that the statement about Medical Lake being a “modern day Pool of Bethesda” applies to the modern time this book is being written in, but the “minister” they are referring to is Rev. Jonathan Edwards,  who wrote “An Illustrated History of Spokane County” published in the year 1900!]

They later discovered that the Pool of Bethesda mentioned in the Bible is located right outside of a Catholic church called “St. Annes.”  They were excited to realize that the name of the Catholic church by the “modern-day pool of Bethesda” was also called “St. Anne’s.”

After one more fast and one more trip to Spokane, Tim and Tom felt that the Lord told them their part was finished.  As Cal Pierce listened to the stories Tim and Tom had been telling, he said “I felt like my hand had accidentally been stuck in a light socket. God was doing something powerful!” (pg 79)

This chain of “meant to be experiences,” and amazing “coincidences” just keeps going and going.  I can see how these stories could be convincing to anyone who puts a lot of stock in amazing experiences.  “How could it not be the work of God?” they would think.  However, how can any of this be verified?  It is just hearsay.  The stories being told by Tim and Tom are especially suspect because the same stories are told so differently in Cal Pierce’s audio presentation regarding “Preparing the Way.”

The Saturday night after Cal’s phone conversation with Tim, Tim called Cal again and asked him, “What did you do?”  Cal thought he was asking about the day of prayer that they had just completed, and he started to tell him about it, but Tim interrupted and said “No, I mean what did you do after I told you about Medical Lake?

Cal told him that he couldn’t stand to wait any longer to investigate this mystery so he drove out to Medical Lake and brought some home with him.  Tim then told him, that was what he needed to hear.  Cal was fulfilling the prophecy by Bob Jones so that “the anointing for healing would start outside the city, come into the city, and then go around the world.” (pg 79)

As I stated earlier, Medical Lake is my home town, and this sounded absurd to me, then I couldn’t believe what I was reading.  Cal stated “In our Healing Rooms, we keep a vase containing water from Medical Lake.  We have come to call it ‘firewater’ because when we touch people with it, they say it feels hot to them.  It isn’t hot in the natural, but it apparently is in the Spirit.  We anoint those who come to our Healing Rooms with oil,* as the Bible teaches, but when we do conferences, we impart with Medical Lake water.” (pgs 79-80)

*They don’t use olive oil like they did in Scripture.  They have their own oil that is made from almond oil.  They mix it with Frankincense, Myrrh and Cinnamon. (pg 133)

If I had only been reading this about a place I knew nothing of, I would just think that this was a little bit strange.  But since this lake had been in my own backyard so to speak, it felt like someone came into my house, took water out of my toilet, and began anointing people with it as some kind of healing water.


Re-digging the Wells

Cal now goes on to describe in detail what happened that Saturday during their day of prayer.  It was May 29, 1999.  More than 100 people responded to the invitation to attend.  As a group they first visited the grave site of John G. Lake, then the Lake home and the old tabernacle. They then finished the day at the Rookery building.  Cal hadn’t leased the rooms yet, but the owners of the building let them use some rooms for the special day.

Everyone formed a “human chain of prayer” that moved in an out of the four rooms and in and out of the hallways.  At one point, Cal said he “went down the line, anointing each person in the chain with water from Medical Lake.  Many of them were slain in the Spirit.” (pg 83)

Three rooms had brown carpet, but the fourth room had a silver carpet.  This later came to be known as the Silver Room.  When he got into the Silver Room, he saw that everyone was on the floor.  So he anointed them where they were.  Cal recalls that a couple of days later, a woman sent him a letter.  She said that she was the first one in the Silver Room.  As soon as she entered she fell to the floor and couldn’t stand back up.  Then everyone that came into the room after she did, also fell to the floor, because “the anointing was so powerful.

Again, as I stated early on in this article, I Corinthians 14:32 states “the spirit of the prophet is subject to the prophet” so if something is forcing you to do something such as causing you to fall on the floor, it cannot be the Holy Spirit.

Later, Cal carried in some boxes and after sitting them down, he went into the Silver Room to see what the lady had been referring to.  He claims that when he went through the door to the Silver Room, “it was like going through a curtain of anointing.”  To make sure he wasn’t imagining it, He states that he did this over and over again for about 20 minutes—stepping into the room then out of the room, and it would happen each time.

The next day, when he moved in some more boxes, he asked God “What is it that makes the anointing so powerful in that room?”  He said that the Lord answered him “I left an angel in that room, and he has been waiting now for eighty years for the rooms to be reopened for prayer.  As long as my angel is there, this healing anointing will pour out from this place and will go around the world.” (pg 84)

[NOTE:  Keep in mind, this building is not the same building that John G. Lake’s healing rooms were in, that building burnt down, and a new building was built in its place.]

In an audio presentation given by Cal Pierce while he was still writing his book, he indicates that this angel from the Silver Room goes with him when he goes out to conferences.  He recounts a story where He and Bill Johnson did a conference in Brunswick, and they did a week’s worth of taping on Sid Roth’s Messianic Vision radio program.  Sid Roth told Cal—

You know, I’ve heard of this angel in the Silver Room.  I’ve heard that it goes out with you when you go out to do these conferences.  Can it be on assignment?”

Cal responded, “Well, I don’t know, maybe.”

When the taping was over, Cal went up to his room to put his card in the door.  He states that “I heard a voice down the hallway saying ‘Reverend, your room is ready.

I turned and looked and there was two cleaning ladies about halfway down the hallway.  I said, ‘how did you know I was a Reverend?’

The lady said, ‘Well I saw you leave this morning, I told my friend here when you left that, that’s a preacher, and my friend said, “Well, how do you know that?”’

And I said, ‘Well, because I saw the angel leave with him this morning.’”

Cal then states: “I had never seen the lady before and she had never seen me before, I don’t even know if she is a Christian.” (Pierce, Audio File)

Cal goes on to state “After the Healing Rooms were reopened, more than six hundred pastors would make their way into that room, [the Silver Room] and each time we would ask them what they felt.  Invariably they answered ‘The Presence of Angels.’” (pg 85)

In a book called “The Physics of Heaven” there is a chapter written from an interview of Cal Pierce where he talks about another angel that came to him after a meeting. Cal states:

“As soon as the session ended, I looked up to see an angel standing right in front of me.  I’m not an angel type of guy, but suddenly there was an angel speaking to me saying, ‘I’m sent by God to answer your question about the energy crisis.  I am the energy angel.’  All I could think was, ‘What on earth did I have for breakfast?'”

He goes on to tell how the angel gave him the blueprints for a “water car” and showed him how energy could be produced with water and light.  It was a nice day outside, so Cal asked the angel if he wanted to take a walk.  The angel answered “I’ve been walking with you for 30 years but you just didn’t know it.

Does Cal ever test the teachings of these angels?  Does he even question that they could be something “other than” an angel of God?  Paul states in 2 Corinthians 11:14 that even “Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light.”

Spirit guides, who sometimes appear as angels, often as beings of light, or even as Jesus himself, are very active in New “Age” Spirituality.  For more information see “Whatever Happened to the New Age? Parts 1 and 2,” and “Spirit Guides Coming to a Church Near You.

The Reopening of the Healing Rooms

After the day of prayer, they began to recruit and train a group of people who would serve in the Healing Rooms.  Cal taught five classes which covered the following instruction:  [NOTE: Remember I’m just quoting him, I don’t necessarily agree with anything and/or everything in the list]

  • The provision of divine healing as part of our Salvation
  • God’s many promises concerning healing for His people
  • The special anointing that empowers us to minister healing
  • Roadblocks to healing—things that get in the way of a person’s receiving God’s promises
  • The Spiritual authority we have as Spirit-filled believers
  • The Baptism of the Holy Spirit that seals us and enables us to flow in God’s power

Finally, they studied the process they felt led to establish for the Healing Rooms. (pg 87)

On July 22, 1999 the Healing Rooms were officially opened.  Cal states that the process that they established for the Healing Rooms worked very well.   “We would have a small team, usually with three members, to pray in each of the Healing Rooms.” (pg 91)  One person acted as the leader, and the other two would follow his or her lead.  When sick people arrived they would be met in the reception room and given forms to fill out much like at a doctor’s office.

In addition to the person’s general information, there were two boxes to check:  “Are you born again?” and “Are you filled with the Holy Spirit?”  There was also a space to describe their physical issue.   The information sheet was given to the next available team to be prayed over.  As they did this, they were seeking God for a particular healing strategy.  Cal continues:

“They would soon see the person, but only after the explosion of anointing that came through their prayer time together and only after they had some confirmation about how to proceed with the ministry to that person.  In this way, the ministry would never become just another routine.  Each sick person was a new challenge, and we were determined to find God’s unique answer for each one.” (pg 92)

He claims that the healing team became very gifted regarding this.  As they all prayed six to eight hours a day in the Healing Rooms they began to experience all nine gifts of the Spirit.

“Even though our particular gifting was the gifts of healing, all of the gifts were there, available to minister to the sick. Many of the team members began to speak out words of knowledge, as the Spirit revealed something about the sick person or the sickness involved and what was necessary to overcome it.  This proved to be a powerful ministry tool.”  [emphasis mine]

In the Healing Rooms official instruction book “How to Minister to Specific Diseases,” it states on a page right after the introduction:

“Information for this book has been gathered through many thousands of prayer sessions in the Spokane Healing Rooms.  Scriptures are given on each disease as the Holy Spirit directed our team.

Root causes to sickness have been known by the medical industry for decades.  We have identified spiritual root causes by interviewing those prayed for.  Certain symptoms of sickness have similar root causes.  We simply have linked those which are most common root causes to specific diseases.  Our goal is to bring an awareness of what those root causes are, and how to minister healing.” (Healing Rooms)

This appears to be the “ministry tool” that is being referred to.   It is interesting how they go from root causes to sickness that the medical industry recognizes to support their position, but then they do a kind of  “bait and switch” saying that they have identified spiritual root causes.  [I doubt the medical industry would agree with that.]

Everyone should understand that correlation DOES NOT prove causation.  This kind of research would need to be done under very strict guidelines and a controlled environment to prove anything.  Even if these root cause were actually shown to be associated with these diseases, who is to say that the so- called “root causes” aren’t the resulting behaviors and issues caused by the disease?

Here are some of the examples of the so-called “Root Causes” they list in the book:

Alzheimer’s:  Self-hatred, self-rejection, shame and guilt
Arthritis:  Usually involves bitterness from unforgiveness toward others or yourself
Autism:  Can be Generational.*  Rejection, rebellion, anger, self-hatred, spirit of fear, deaf and dumb spirit, and self-condemnation
Cystic Fibrosis:   Inherited disease.  Fear and anxiety problem.  (What!?)
Diabetes:  Extreme  rejection and self-hatred coupled with guilt.  Can be inherited through an unloving  spirit from parents or grandparents.  Could be a generational curse.
Hypoglycemia:  Worry, fear, fear of rejection, not trusting God, self-hatred; could be hereditary.
Parkinson’s:  Unresolved rejection, self-rejection, abandonment, hope deferred.
Stroke:   Could be generational.  Stress, anxiety, and anger.  Self-rejection, self-bitterness, self-hatred.
Varicose Veins:  Internalization of hurts that are caused by anger and resentment.  Usually inherited.

*Later in the book it indicates that what they mean by “generational” is that it is a generational curse.

Then they list the root causes for a number of different types of Cancer:

Cancer:  Can be deeply rooted bitterness, anger, guilt, and self-hatred.  Can be generational.
Colon Cancer:  Bitterness, slander, possibly generational with division making—contention.
Liver Cancer:  Lusting after a female, mentally or actually.  Often involving pornography, fornication, drugs and/or alcohol addiction.  Also bitterness.
Breast Cancer:  Conflict and bitterness between the female and her mother, sisters, or mother-in-law.
Ovarian Cancer:  Woman’s hatred for self and her sexuality and self-bitterness
Uterine Cancer:  Bitterness and self-bitterness; promiscuity and uncleanness
Hodgkin’s Disease & Leukemia:  Deep rooted bitterness coming from unresolved rejection by a father
Prostrate:  Bitterness, unforgiveness toward males in the family, fornication, fear.

Then the procedures for healing from the various diseases are given.  This is for cancer:

  • Re-establish Christ’s redemption from the curse
  • Lead them to forgiveness and repentance to the Father for wrongly discerning the broken body of Jesus (Taking the bread in doubt and unbelief)
  • Deal with any deep emotional hurts through forgiveness and repentance
  • Take communion with them, if possible, rightly discerning what Jesus did on the cross.
  • Bind and cast out the spirit of cancer
  • Command the cells to function normally
  • Command healing to all organs and tissue effected by the cancer


The Expansion of the Healing Rooms

Cal Pierce began receiving invitations to teach conferences on healing.  Eventually he was doing two each month. To each conference he indicates that he takes with him some Medical Lake water and uses it to “impart the healing anointing to the Body of Christ in each place.” (pg 104)

Also, Healing Rooms began to be opened in many places in the United States and in other countries.  Because of this, they started an organization called “The International Association of Healing Rooms.”  They began doing a bimonthly training program at the Spokane Healing Rooms.

Cal tells of two important visions he had about the healing ministry in the end times.  He believes that they are being fulfilled by the Healing Rooms.

His first vision came to him on his first trip to Spokane.  He claims he saw “a giant lying in the valley.  His head was in Spokane, and his feet extended all the way to Coeur d’Alene, Idaho, thirty miles away.” (pg 107)  He saw cobwebs and thin looking cords covering the giant similar to the story of Gulliver.  The giant looked like he had just been born there and grew to maturity, but had never moved. He could move, but he didn’t because he didn’t think he could.  There was no way that the flimsy looking cords could have held him down if he had tried to move.

Cal states “I sensed that the giant I was seeing was the Church, not just in Spokane, but around the country.  If we could just get all of the parts moving together, nothing could hold us back.” (pg 107)

The second vision came to him just before the Healing Rooms opened.  He was driving across the Maple Street Bridge.  As he looked over the city he saw that it was dark.  Cal states that God showed him that “the enemy had held God’s people captive too long.”

He then began to see flashes of light and “in the Spirit” he was raised up to about the same height as the mountains around the city and could see for great distances.  There were white horses at the outskirts of the city in every direction.  The might army of horses moved in unison and the pounding of the hooves shook the ground.  Lightning was flashing from their swords.  “Suddenly, the windows of Heaven began to open, the sky rolled back, and I was looking into the heavens.  A voice like a roaring lion came from Heaven, saying ‘Let my People go.” (pg 108-9)

Cal believes these were confirming the prophecy given by Bob Jones, “that the healing anointing would begin outside the city of Spokane and then go out from there around the world.”  He believes that “the greatest move of the Holy Spirit the world has ever seen is about to take place through the Church, through the army that God is calling together and raising up.” (pg 110)

Can you lose Your Healing?

On page 125 of Preparing the Way, there is a statement regarding healing that says this:  “Many people lose their healing because they turn their attention from the seed of God’s promise and concentrate on their circumstances or symptoms.  Pain, for instance, is a terrible distraction.”

In the back of the healing instruction manual “How to Minister to Specific Diseases” it has an article called “How to Keep Your Healing.”  It misapplies the parable of the sower which speaks of the different types of people who hear the gospel and how they respond, to being about how we are healed:

“When we receive the Word on healing and are prayed for and a healing takes place, we receive it with joy, but it must become firmly rooted in us because the devil will always try to inflict us with the very same symptoms to change our minds.  Verse 21 says because of the Word, this affliction will be brought against us once again to cause us to fall away. [Say what? Matthew 13:21 says this?]

The devil will once again bring the symptoms of the sickness to try and convince us that we are not healed.  This is a lying vanity.  The root meaning of a lying vanity is something that comes against you to change your mind.  If the devil can cause us to look at symptoms instead of God’s promise, he can convince us to believe his lie.  When we focus on the symptoms, pain or whatever it is, doubt and unbelief come to our mind and this gives entrance for fear to re-establish the sickness.  We must keep our heart and mind fixed upon God and His promise.”

Is this Scriptural?  Misapplying Scripture doesn’t count.

1.  Anyone who seriously studies the Bible would come up with some very quick responses to the idea of “losing your healing.”  First of all, there is absolutely no account in the Bible of anyone ever “losing” their healing.  In about 99% of all accounts the healing took place immediately. The 1% were Naaman in the OT (2 Kings 5:10-14)  and the blind man who saw “men as trees walking” in the NT (Mark 8:22-25).  In 100% of all accounts the healing was permanent!

2.  The information regarding “keeping your healing” puts all of the responsibility on the person being healed.  If the person isn’t healed, then the people in the Healing Rooms praying for them can just say, well sorry, we did our part, you just didn’t have enough faith to keep your healing.  There are a number of healings in the New Testament where no faith at all was required from the person being healed.

–The lame man at the “Gate called Beautiful” was just looking for a handout when Peter said “Silver and Gold have I none, but such as I have give I thee, in the name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth, rise up and walk.” (Acts 3:2-8)

–The widow from Nain and her dead son.  No faith was required of him or his mother.  Jesus saw them, had compassion and raised her son from the dead. (Luke 7:11-15).  All accounts of the dead being raised required no faith from the person being raised.

–The Centurian’s servant. (Luke 7:2-10)  No faith was required of the sick servant.  He was healed because of the Centurian’s faith.

3.  Jesus made it clear that the disciples did not need to “increase” their faith.  He said that all they needed was faith the size of a mustard seed and anything would be possible. (Luke 17:5-6).  It is not the size of the Faith that matters because it is not source of the power, it is WHO you have faith in that has the power—God!  Trying to drum up enough faith is trying to obtain your healing through your own efforts, it is your own “works.”  We are not healed by our efforts, God is the one who heals us.

If a person has the same symptoms he or she has NOT been healed.  No healing in Scripture indicated that the symptoms came back.  The blind man who was healed didn’t go around with a daisy in his hand pulling off the petals saying “I can see!”  “oh, now I can’t”  “I can see!”  “Oh, now I can’t” fluctuating according to his belief or lack of belief.

It is identical to the concept of “positive thinking” in which you have to keep believing or the symptoms will return.  It reminds me of Gilligan on the old show “Gilligan’s Island” where Gilligan has a pair of wings on that he made and he is hovering in thin air until the Skipper says “Gilligan, you can’t fly!” and Gilligan says “I can’t?” and then falls to the ground.

When God heals you, you are healed!  Satan cannot do anything about it. Nothing in Scripture indicates that Satan can make you have symptoms so that you will believe you’re not healed.

Also, there are no instructions for lengthy investigation and procedures to accomplish healing in Scripture.  There was no “healing manual.”  Jesus simply said “be healed” and they were healed—the Apostles said “be healed” and they were healed.  Being God, the Holy Spirit knows the cause “if any” of any disease, he doesn’t need us to help him out.

The only instructions given is what it says in James 5:14 where it states:  “Is any sick among you?  Let him call for the elders of the church; and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord.  And the prayer of faith shall save the sick, and the Lord shall raise him up; and if he have committed sins, they shall be forgiven him.”

Notes:

History. Welcome to the City of Medical Lake. Medical-lake.org. 2014. Web. 12 Mar. 2014. http://www.medical-lake.org/community/history.asp

Franklin, Judy and Ellyn Davis.  “Chapter 9.”  The Physics of Heaven.  Double Portion Publishing, 2012. Print.

Pierce, Cal. Preparing the Way:  The Reopening of the John G. Lake Healing Rooms in Spokane, Washington.  Maryland: McDougal Publishing, 2001. Print.

Pierce, Cal. (Audio File) Preparing the Way: The History of the Healing Rooms. NCSanDiegoHealingRooms.com. 2014. Web. 12 Mar. 2014.   http://www.ncsandiegohealingrooms.com/about-us/history

Healing Rooms. How to Minister to Specific Diseases. nd. Spokane: Healing Rooms Ministries. Print.




The Daniel Plan

In January of 2011, the Saddleback Church and Rick Warren kicked off a new year-long program to lose weight and get healthy called “The Daniel Plan.”  It is the first initiative in what Warren calls “a Decade of Destiny.”

Three well-known doctors have been enlisted to develop and implement a comprehensive plan.  They are–Dr. Daniel Amen, Dr. Mark Hymen and well-known TV doctor, Dr. Mehmet Oz.

Undoubtedly, these doctors have a lot of excellent medical advice, however, interspersed with all of the good advice are New (Age) Spirituality techniques such as mystical meditation, and energy healing methods such as Reiki (pronounced Ray-kee).

This was made evident by the very first interview of Dr. Amen for the Daniel Plan, he stated “There is a meditation exercise from Harvard–It’s not religious at all, it’s called the ‘relaxation response.’  Take a big breath, blow it out.  Every time you breath out, say the word ‘one.’  Do it for 10 minutes, you’ve got all these thoughts coming into your head.  Imagine a big broom–sweep them away.”   [Emphasis mine]

Well, I could possibly be persuaded to agree that it might not be actually religious, but it certainly has mystical/spiritual effects.  The instructions given are the exact ones given for any form of mystical meditation–relaxing, slow methodical breathing, repeating a single word over and over again (it doesn’t matter what word you choose), doing this for at least 10 minutes a day, and clearing your mind of all thoughts.  You’ll find these basic instructions for any form of mystical meditation you hear about including the “Christianized” version called Centering or Contemplative Prayer.  It doesn’t matter what you call it, it is still mystical meditation which produces an altered state of consciousness and opens you up to negative influences from the spiritual realm.

In an article by Lighthouse Trails Research…

On the video interview with Rick Warren and Dr. Amen,Warren states that Dr. Amenʼs resources would be available for those attending the seminar this coming weekend. In almost all of the ‘resources’ by Dr. Amen, he advocates eastern meditation. In some of the books, he devotes many, many pages to meditation practices. On page 238 of Amenʼs Making a Good Brain Great, he states: ‘I recommend an active form of yoga meditation called Kriya Kirtan. It is based on the five primal sounds saa, taa, naa, maa, aa.” He tells readers to repeat these sounds for 12 minutes straight.’ ” [Emphasis mine]

Dr. Hyman also is a strong advocate of mystical meditation.  In the same article by Lighthouse Trails Research, it states…

In his book, The Ultramind Solution, Hyman emphasizes meditation, saying that it doesnʼt matter what religion one has to benefit from it (p. 322). Dr. Hyman suggests that “Mindful meditation is a powerful well-researched tool, developed by Buddhists” (p. 384).”

And last, but not least, On January 9, 2010, Dr. Mehmet Oz told 2 million viewers to “try Reiki.”  Dr. Oz’s wife, Lisa, is a Reiki Master who called Reiki “my favorite treatment that could change the future of medicine forever.”

Reiki supposedly balances out your energy to facilitate healing.  A Reiki treatement typically consists of the Reiki Practitioner holding their hand a few inches above different parts of the body.  According to many Reiki experts and websites, it incorporates the assistance of Spirit Guides, whether the practitioners choose to acknowledge them or not.

New (Age) Spirituality practices of all kinds—mystical meditation and contemplative prayer, Yoga, Reiki, labrynths, communication with the spirit world, etc., all lead to the same belief system that is diametrically opposed to Biblical Christianity–interspirituality (all paths lead to God), Panentheism (God is in all),  and universalism (all are saved).  They are paving the way for the one world religious belief system yet to come.